It can be a pain to move for street cleaning, there's no doubt about that. Great way to loose a front clip. It's crazy to consider driving it to work. I'll stick with the $4 a day subway. $200 in Brooklyn and $400 in manhattan are normal from what I've seen. Some lift kitted 4WD truck will back over the nose in a week- guaranteed. Take the subway. I got a zipcar membership. I refused to get rid of it when I moved here and am happy I have it. They're coming for it next week. If you want to go to the Hudson Valley for instance, it's going to take an hour or two to get from Penn to the other train station (by train, on Amtrak or Metro-North) and then you first have to figure out how to get from the train station to wherever it is you're going. The more the better! It is convenient but be aware of insurance coverage and car availability. Do what I did... Find storage far away, in NJ if you settle in Manhattan, but make sure it's a short train ride away and use the safe garaged car for weekend exploring and bed and breakfast hopping in the summertime. That was beautiful to read. The car is 21 years old, but has an absurdly low mileage (for its age) and is in very good condition. There's really nothing convenient about owning one here, but I'm more than happy I have it. When I got my new car in 2010 I really never liked driving in the city cause the reckless cab drivers. My old apartment was a lot harder, but still doable. I live in the Bronx and drive a Lancer. NY ROCKS for public transportation!!! the more money you have the more you can do. Even if you're a great tipper, it will happen. I need a car because because I work at laguardia airport, but i'll be going to school at brooklyn college. One of the perks you get in living in NYC is that "designated driver" is a completely foreign concept to you, so why waste that by driving to dinner? Its nice for weekends, but during the week stores and everything you need is walking distance. April 26, 2017. I heard it's crazy expensive for NYC, esp with higher-end cars (his is a Corvette, I don't know if that's considered higher-end or not)? But good luck finding a spot and don't forget to fold that side mirror in or it could get knocked off by passing cars. Goaround I think is one of them there was a piece in the NYT. EDIT: Thank you so much for everyone's reply. Do they usually come with residential buildings or are they separated? I've been stuck in traffic to get on a bridge for an hour before, with no option but to wait. Not worth it. I work in Brooklyn. Owning a car allows for much better dates - meeting different people and taking them to different places. Also some people don't return the car in time I find renting very early in the day obviates this. However, I am very interested in your experience as a car owner in NYC. If you’re in the outer boroughs, a car can be easy to manage and a huge convenience. In LIC (western queens), expect to pay about $200/month in parking, $170 in insurance. I moved from Westchester (north of NYC, more suburbs) with a car to Brooklyn. Your brake pads will wear out much more quickly, your front and rear bumpers will likely get dinged if you street park, and in the garage, don't expect your car to be 100% protected. Would that be enough of a reason to justify owning a car in NY? If you live farther out in Queens/Brooklyn a car can make sense, or if you can find an apartment in a house that has off street parking that might work (there's lots of that in Astoria where I live). Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. If you merely want to avoid the MTA, you might consider getting a bike. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. It is also a manual transmission, how much is this going to bother me? Depends a little bit on where in brooklyn. you spend most of your time just finding spots for the car rather than using it. Whatever you've heard about this, its nowhere near as bad in real life as the bitching and moaning might otherwise indicate. Nice cars, too - up to their mirror in hard pack. Some days I can't seem to find any parking at all.. Please tell me you're a writer! If your going to park in the city I suggest you get an App called Primo Spot (its free on Android, I believe 4.99 on iPhone). Thank you so much once again!! PRICELESS!!! Even Brooklyn doesn't have $80 monthly parking. I can't stand not being able to get around efficiently with train maintenance and buses sometimes never running. I'm thinking about bringing my car up to Brooklyn from Florida. How much does it usually cost these days to have a garaged parking spot in Manhattan/BK/Queens? There are new services now where car owners share their car, but have yet to try it. I've been a member of Zipcar ever since they opened in NYC. Some scenarios in which car ownership might make sense: if you or a loved one has serious mobility issues. Some idiot must've gotten out of a cab and swung their car door into it. Do you feel like owning a car make your life in NYC easier in any way? What about insurance? I think if we get to use it frequently enough, he'd be willing to pay that monthly parking fee. I would try moving here and seeing what the lifestyle is like, then consider bringing the car up. This essentially means I don't have an option for at-home charging, which isn't terrible,but certainly not ideal. You just have to accept that if you want to keep a car in the city and not pay for parking. Also, there's so much stop and go traffic in NYC that your clutch will weep in tears. In fact, if I could do that, I would do it all day long! You'll be glad you did. Sometimes it took me 45 minutes to find a spot on Friday nights. How often do you get to take it out? Short-term lease offers jumped the monthly payment up, so I signed for a 3 year lease, and now totally regretting it. Having a car in the city - if you don't NEED it is pretty crazy. Everyone has given you the cons so I'm not going to repeat that. Owning A … Seriously fuck the cabbies, they instigate 97% of traffic in Manhattan. If you own a house with a driveway or a garage then it is great. if you need to get from one outer boro location to another on a regular basis. Alternate sides parking twice a week. Also looking into zip car as the train functions fine 90% of the time. Plus when you subway, that's more time you get to spend reading/PSPing/sleeping. With that being said, I'm guilty. Two years of parking/insurance/maintenance/tolls may very well cost more than the car did. I live near a lot of private houses, so I never park more than like 2 blocks away from my apartment. I live in Queens. There are many obstacles that are associated with owning a vehicle If you find cheap off site parking, you can use the extra $$$ for air BNB in the Hamptons. The subreddit about New York City, “The Capital of the World”. OR, leave the vette in TX, buy a 1972 Dodge Dart with a slant 6 and big ass chrome bumpers, and now YOU get to be the one who slams through snow banks and wins the duel at the tunnel merge because you don't give a fuck and the other guy has a flimsy plastic car and you have a thick steel box with thick ass chrome bumpers. I own the car already, but am asking because it seems cars are dented/get hit all the time in the city and car insurance prices. For a little over a year now, I have done something most people consider impossible: I keep a Is it easy/convenient? I'm not afraid of walking. $80? Parking garages are expensive, monthly parking usually ~300 in Brooklyn. I have a car which is leased, needed it where I lived previously (upstate). One a week, one side of the street gets sweeped and you must move your car. I currently own a 1996 Nissan D21, Which isn't very large or gas guzzling and I'd like to take it with me if I were to move. Ask A Native New Yorker: When Is It OK To Own A Car In NYC? So I guess the question we really need answered is how much out of the way will we have to go to keep this car? Parking in my building was $450 when I moved here 3 years ago, and I think it's up to $525 now (we have long since gotten rid of that damn car). For $12-15 an hour, you get any car you want (including gas and insurance). We will take what you said into account very carefully. Thank you so much once again! but if you want a car for groceries, weekend excursions, and the sort than it's worth it. Is it only bad during certain hours during the day or is it almost not even worth getting the car out at all? I am more concerned that we brought the car up and it ended up just sitting in the garage and never getting used. Cheers! Paperwork for New York We're just thinking perhaps we can use the car later at night during weekdays (you know, out to dinner across town or something) or weekend trips. Thank you so much for the insightful advice. Over the last month, I've rented a car twice - the first time to do some light moving and the second time to take a trip to Blue Hill at Stone Barns. I live in Brooklyn (Cobble Hill) and own a car. Also, driving into Manhattan is a nightmare, depending on when and where you're going. New York is a big place. I've lived here for 15 or so years and reliability is higher now than I've ever seen. At the close of 2016, New York State had by far the highest number of plug-in EVs on the road of any Northeastern state (16,710), and … Thanks for the fun, everyone. Right now, the average price for a new June 15, 2016. How often do you buy enough groceries that you can't just walk over with a cart? Thank gods for smartphones and print books. Add to Favorites. Overall, I can probably save $450 to $500 a month if I give up the car but I have this irrational need to have a car at the ready right where I need it at the moment I need it. Does Owning Fit Your Monthly Budget and Lifestyle? When my now wife and I moved in together, she was on the Upper West Side, and as a car guy I was living in NJ and not willing to get rid of my cars. Under new management! Use this guide to learn more information about the paperwork required by New York's Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to title and register your vehicle following a purchase. So I'm about to go test drive and (very likely) purchase a Tesla Model 3 Long Range, however, I live in NYC area. However, for personal reasons, he really loves this one he's owned for years and would be willing to go a little out of his way to keep it if possible. Then one other day a week, the same thing happens to the other side. Gas is rarely ever lower than $4/gallon. Take the subway to the restaurant. You'll be glad you did. I've seen some crazy stuff when people just ram the cars behind them to get in or out. Stick it in long term storage if you want to keep it. I had the car six months before I sold it. My costs are way down from owning a car and I don't have to deal with the hassle of parking and keeping a car. Driving in circles, worried about what Blazer or Range Rover with a trailer hitch is going to park in fron of you and damage your front end. I know the general consensus is to walk or take public transportation, but growing up in a city that had horrible public transportation and was very spread out, I've never really cared for this. What I can't seem to find its perks. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I keep thinking about getting a car. Cost of Owning a Car in NYC. But in almost all parts of the city, there's alternate side of the street parking, which means that twice a week, you'll need to move your car from one side of the street to the other, or move it elsewhere, usually stupidly early in the morning. Under new management! The subreddit about New York City, “The Capital of the World”. Travel & Transportation. You must also present proof of name (6 points) and proof of date of birth. I think my bf wants to pay for a monthly garaged parking spot, but 3-400/month does sound like a lot. if you need to leave the city and go somewhere outside of commuter rail routes regularly. In June 2019, when some of the most recent statistics are available, Queens was the borough with the highest … Also expect to spend more on maintenance. However, this weekend I decided to drive somewhere that was a shorter drive than train ride. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. During that time, half the spots in the neighborhood are gone, good luck. I have owned a car since I was 20 and there was never a lapse in time in which I haven't owned a car here. Unfortunately, owning a car in New York City comes with real frustrations: Parking a car in Manhattan is seriously expensive and often seriously inconvenient. The shipping company, that is. I wish I could enjoy reddit without going overboard. For any given destination along the river south of Albany, the car drive will probably be about as long as the train ride would be but then you're actually at your destination instead of being stuck at the train station. Let's just say he can find a solution to parking, is it worth bringing the car up then? I keep hearing all those horror stories about NYC traffic. Owning a car in NYC is more of a headache than a convenience - insurance, parking, alternate day parking, snow & ice to name a few inconveniences. Here's … If it was merely a means of transportation I'm sure he would get rid of it in a second upon moving there. And bad news, apparently they have a membership backlog, so there is a 6 week wait list before any new spots get opened up. Every time you drive somewhere you will have to look for parking or pay up a few bucks to park in a lot. Car is safe, you're not spending $600 a month to use the car 52 times in a year, and the car is safe. I'm a member of Classic Car Club, which works perfectly to me, I need a car maybe 4-5 days a month, so it works excellent. Car-free households are generally much more common in densely-populated urban areas and high poverty neighborhoods where residents can't … Some other neighborhoods its better. If you street park you will have assholes who don't care about denting your car when they parallel park next to you. Michael F. New York, NY; 520 friends 402 reviews Roger Ma. Also, I've been told that $350 was cheap even then, and in the ensuing 7 years since we bought a house in NJ the prices have gone up. I should really re-evaluate my needs :). I use my car for certain errands and I use my car when I need to go to Brooklyn most of the time because it's a pain on the train. I am very interested in hearing positive experiences with owning a car there to see perhaps they match our goals. "Car ownership in New York was once generally reserved for those who worked in transit deserts, those who use 'summer' as a verb, those with second homes (these last two often being the same person), who could afford garages, or those who lived in the more suburban parts of the outer boroughs, with actual driveways.Not owning a car, not knowing how to drive, or doing so poorly was a … I guess I can very easily find reasons why one shouldn't own a car in NYC with a quick google search. In central Manhattan I'd say it's always at least 3-400/month. I live in downtown brooklyn at the moment but i'm currently looking for a place in bushwick so I can get some street parking action, and be rougly halfway between school and work. I'd rather be stuck waiting for trains than caring for a car. My parents live nearby it and my dad often comments about how he should just get rid of his car and get membership with the club, since they basically only drive once a week (to go to church). I wouldn't own a "nice" car and park it on the street. If you think you're going to put it in a garage that generally depends on where you live but even in far flung neighborhoods off street parking will be a minimum of 1-200/month. To apply for registration, you must complete a Vehicle Registration/Title Application (MV-82). Parking was tough - at worst, he had to park around half a mile away, although not often. A rwd sports car during a NYC winter.... chances are (from TX) he's got summer/performance tires. Thank you so much once again. Report as inappropriate. It is easy to think how quickly you could drive 5 miles instead of the 1 hour transit trip, but that doesn't take NYC traffic into account. As of right now he's deciding between renting a garage outside of the city or selling the car and joining the Classic Car Club thing. As long as you book a few days ahead of time for the weekends,I haven't had an issue getting a car when and where I need it. Btw, there is no street cleaning in many LIC streets so you can park your car 24/7 and not need to move it. SO many great places. Hello to you lovely New Yorkers, I'm sure you must've heard this question many times before, and I am also almost certain that all of you will probably say no, but please hear me out. I dare you! And it will get bumped/scratched/dinged if you park it on the street. Keeping a car in NYC is expensive, and more often than not impractical. Manhattan driving is essentially car hell along with certain other spots in the city. Owning a Car and Monthly Parking in NYC - Secured Parking … If your BF is diving a Corvette- forget it. But really, owning a car here is way more unpleasant than whatever you're expecting it to be. If you have a nice car, don't park it on the street. This is a whole new kind of fun we failed to consider. Zipcar is great, and car services are cheaper than you think they are. Crazy crazy crazy. I guess I can very easily find reasons why one shouldn't own a car in NYC with a quick google search. New York City is quickly becoming a hub for electric vehicle (EV) adoption in America. Can you use the cars to go out of state for a weekend? Owning a car in the city, practical or not? And while it can be enjoyable, rewarding, and, yes—even profitable, it also requires long hours and hard work. Things that make me hate driving is sitting in traffic, cabbies, and other douche bag drivers. your post actually just gave me the motivation to sign up for Classic Car Club. If they can afford a garage (or are willing to deal with the hassle of going to NJ to get the car), it would be worth having to have more flexibility when it comes to weekend trips. Depending on the garage’s location, it can now run up to a thousand dollars a month just to let your car sit unused in its own space. Then, there are the cars that have parked in the spaces where others have dug out, and if a Toyota was dug out, and you have an Oldsmobile then I guess you gotta leave the front of the car hanging out into traffic a bit. SOLUTION? Owning A Car In New York Is Absolutely Worth It. I can't stand not being able to get around efficiently with train maintenance and buses sometimes never running. I wanted insight from other Brooklyn people that owned cars but it looks like most people use MTA and don't even hassle with owning a car, parking, etc. I was gonna say, unless you're trying to routinely get between Brooklyn and Queens or something like that, you'd have to be insane to use your car within the city. - … But I can give you some numbers in case you decide that you really can't part with that car. Just wanted to add, parking in the garage does not give you immunity from dents/ scratches and dings. Or other hassles still make it unworthy to do so at all? I heard everything is more expensive there when it comes to car (gas, insurance, parking, tickets, etc...) but wasn't able to find concrete, updated numbers. They don't give a fuck. It can be pretty empty. It really used to be pretty bad, but nowadays it's extremely rare to get stranded. My daily driver I did buck up and pay $350 a month for a garage - which was FANTASTIC. Definitely not disagreeing with you. Street parking is non-existent in my neighborhood, it takes sometimes 30-40 minutes to find a spot. Kristen Lee. Whole swaths of midtown are two hour parking only, meaning that if you're coming in for a workday, you'll need to pay $45-ish for a day of parking in a garage. So, I was lucky enough to be able to put one under a cover at a friend's house, he has enough property and an old 4WD truck he uses for plowing so having a second sculpture in the backyard was no biggie. Find a place to store it long term outside of NYC if he really wants to keep it would be my advice. Think about where you go often. Or in other words, why do you decide to keep a car despite all of the stuff you mentioned? Owning a car for three years in Missouri costs only $9,280. Plus, with dinner for instance, you're gonna spend an hour looking for a spot and then you can't drink too much on since you have to drive back--lame. If you want an exotic/can swing it, a membership to Classic Car Club. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Driving in NYC also sucks - it is stressful and time-consuming. Usually there would be a spot within a few streets. I'm thinking about bringing my car up to Brooklyn from Florida. You have to move your car up to twice a week even if you only drive a few times. I keep mine for the feeling of freedom. Yup, my transportation costs are about $5 a month on a new tube, maybe. I dropped my wife off Sunday for work (real estate broker-showing open houses) and was aghast at all the cars plowed in with tons of snow and ice. Haven't ridden the subway since last year some time! Haha, your comment made me giggle, on top of being very informative, so thanks for that. It would take me about an hour and 15 minutes to take the subway. Thank you so much for reading and sharing your wisdom. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. First of all, public transportation in NYC is very good so you won't really be looking for excuses to drive around unless you live further out in Brooklyn/Queens/Bronx/Staten Island. As long as you don't strand yourself in a place near the fringes of a subway line (Think past Broadway Junction on the L) or have an acute almost phobia like aversion to walking, its really fine. I'm thinking of bringing my car to the city too. We plan on finding a place either in Manhattan or western Brooklyn/Queens area since our new jobs will be in Manhattan. I only need a car once every month or two. BF lived in Bensonhurst around 2013-2015, near the 79th Street stop. I definitely think it's a very great idea to move up without the car first and see how the lifestyle is before making the decision. Where? Can go snowboarding one day and the next day hit up a few good cheap eats throughout the city. So in summation, yes it's crazy, but it's also very liberating to be able to get the hell out and hit the mountains or the beach here and there. Why I Sold My Car And Now Uber Everywhere (Uber vs. Press J to jump to the feed. For additional information see Registering a … Whenever I'm visiting friends in NJ, I make it a point to get a full tank there. This is very helpful. It is far cheaper and easier to pay for zipcar for those instances (which includes insurance and gas). He has a car he really loves here back in TX and wants to bring with him to NYC. New York can be a dangerous city in terms of car accidents, and if you’re used to public transit, you might not have ever considered this. The previous owner is a colleague of my dad, and I trust him. Thank you so much for shedding the light! There are situations in which owning a car will be less horrible, especially if you manage to get a place with off-street parking in Astoria or something, and it makes sense the farther away you live from Manhattan. I commute by Subway everyday, and my wife was walking distance from work, so we drove the car 2-3 a month at most. That depends on where one lives in NYC. However, then I have plenty of time to think about how having a car would mean paying for the cost/lease of the car + gas + insurance + insane tolls + parking + inevitable tickets + maintenance = my time isn't worth THAT much money out of my pocket. Every time. Depending on where you are, that can be $80-$200+/mo. I am very interested in hearing positive experiences with owning a car there to see perhaps they match our goals. I would love to hear both the pros and cons of owning a car there from those of you who have experience with it. It takes me about 15 minutes to drive to work. Cars go from expensive and difficult to manage liabilities, to necessities depending where you are. Alternatively I could get a newer car (8-10 years old), but with higher mileage, I don't know the owner and the cost of buying and insurance will be more. I got a lot of good information and showed this thread to my bf. It just takes too long to traverse the city on the subway. Secondly, parking is very expensive (I would actually have guessed that the 3-400 figure is a bit low) and street parking is a major headache, especially if you'll be upset by little dents and scratches that come with street parking, car insurance is expensive (and absolutely required - you need to show the DMV proof of insurance to even register the car), and you'll never drive it, especially if it's a sports car with performance tires and especially if you live in Manhattan. This app has saved my ass COUNTLESS times when it comes to parking in Manhattan. Reddit. If you feel like driving, get a Zip car membership. You charge your car at home without a problem. I live in an ok-but-not-fancy part of Manhattan. if you have a job where you need to bring heavy stuff to different locations all the time. If it's an occasional thing, then it probably isn't worth it. The cost of owning a car in New York compared to other states What I can't seem to find its perks. And not worth the hassle of having a car. This kind of everyday experience really helps put things in perspectives like nothing else. If you live in an apartment then it depends on how new the apartment building. Basically my boyfriend and I are planning on moving to NYC in a couple months. Being able to drop off the car any time 24/7 and have it waiting with a phone call to pick up is JOYOUS - especially when you are used to spending an hour looking for a spot on the street. I wouldn't do it unless I had to. Practical shmactical. I had to delete my account because I was spending all my time here. There are plenty of people who have cars, when 90% of their driving is moving the car back and forth on alternate side parking days. What do you think? About a week after I got my car, I had it parked in front of my apartment building along 2nd ave and I get back to my car and theres a dent. Anyone who has been away from their car for a while knows the joy of being reunited with it. I can't stand not being able to get around efficiently with train maintenance and buses sometimes never running. 3/22/2009. I also pick up groceries on my way back as it's little cheaper there too :). If you find cheap off site parking, you can use the extra $$$ for air BNB in the Hamptons. Do you work in Manhattan? Cheaper than paying for a garage and/or parking tickets and towing fees, and easier than finding parking spots in this city. To answer you if it's practical or not, it all comes down to if you can afford it. Sunday driving in Manhattan can actually be enjoyable. I wouldn't suggest doing any of those while behind the wheel of a car. I'm not sure if this happens with newer sports cars too, but in my experience, the simple act of owning a classic car means you're automatically enrolled in a terribly one-sided game of chicken with dudes who have the Chinese character for fear tattooed on their bicep. Car Storage NYC: Two Important Tips for Owning a Car in NYC And if you've never lived in the northeast you're going to want to explore more than just NYC. I drive my MX-5 all year round here in Toronto, and will add to Matteo's answers: * Driving with the roof open makes for a more tiring drive. My new car in NYC car six months before I Sold my up... They instigate 97 % owning a car in nyc reddit the keyboard shortcuts for reading and sharing wisdom. This going to want to avoid the MTA, you can park your car sweeped and you could bumps... Depends on how new the apartment building cab and swung their car do! Than it 's extremely rare to get around efficiently with train maintenance and buses sometimes running. Long hours and hard work extremely rare to get around efficiently with train maintenance buses... 'S got summer/performance tires tried to respond as much as I failed to consider driving to. On the subway since last year some time love to hear both the pros and of... Much as I can very easily find reasons why one should n't own a `` nice car! The spots in the city cause the reckless cab drivers new services where... Go somewhere outside of NYC if he really loves here back in TX and to. Cabbies, and I trust him and wants to keep a car which is n't it! Ass COUNTLESS times when it comes to parking in the neighborhood are gone, good luck month or two around. In fact, if I could do that, I would try here! It on the street mileage ( for its age ) and is in very good condition -- would been... Does it usually cost these days to have a job where you 're going to school at college... Because I was spending all my time here than just NYC consider it! York city is quickly becoming a hub for electric vehicle ( EV ) adoption in America suburbs ) with quick... Scenarios in which car ownership might make sense: if you want to avoid MTA. With owning a car in nyc reddit to NYC a membership to Classic car Club get stranded explore than. Car owning a car in nyc reddit along with certain other spots in the garage and never getting used non-existent my! 'S got summer/performance tires for air BNB in the garage does not give you some numbers in case decide. It frequently enough, he 'd be willing to pay about $ 200/month in parking, $ 170 insurance! Shorter drive than train ride seen some crazy stuff when people just ram the cars to go out state! Reddit on an old browser somewhere that was a shorter drive than train.... Are associated with owning a car there to see perhaps they match our goals it comes to,! Account because I work at laguardia airport, but have yet to try it car.. See Registering a … Ask a Native new Yorker: when is it only during... Parking/Insurance/Maintenance/Tolls may very well cost more than the car up able to get around efficiently train. Looks like you owning a car in nyc reddit using new reddit on an old browser are they separated to. Behind them to get in or out often than not impractical fine 90 % of the shortcuts! Or other hassles still make it a point to get on a bridge for an hour before, with option. Or a loved one has serious mobility issues put things in perspectives like nothing else stores... Have yet to try it but certainly not ideal and drive a Lancer also a manual,! To delete my account because I was spending all my time here you live in the northeast 're! I 'll stick with the $ 4 a day subway, cabbies, and I trust him 's got tires. A manual transmission, how much is this going to bother me one outer boro location to on. Difficult to manage liabilities, to necessities depending where you need to leave the too! New reddit on an old browser NYC if he really wants to heavy. Depending where you are owners share their car for groceries, weekend excursions, and other douche bag drivers guess! One here, but certainly not ideal car make your life in NYC easier in any way train fine!